April 25, 2024

Bucks Blog: Use of Mortgage Interest Deduction Depends on Where You Live

Newly built homes in Atlanta.European Pressphoto Agency Newly built homes in Atlanta.

An analysis from the Pew Charitable Trusts finds that the use of the mortgage interest deduction varies widely across the country, with concentrations on the East Coast and in the West, and in areas with higher property values. The average size of the deduction varies, too.

Less populated areas use it less, the report found, so any change in the deduction is likely to be felt differently in various geographic areas. The analysis uses Internal Revenue Service state-level data from 2010 and ZIP code data from 2007 on the number of tax returns, the number of mortgage interest deduction claims, the amount of interest deducted and federal income taxes paid.

As the federal government looks for ways to reduce the deficit, the mortgage interest deduction — along with other tax deductions and exemptions — is coming under scrutiny.

Tax filers who own a home and itemize deductions are allowed to subtract interest paid on a mortgage from their income. In 2011, filers deducted about $360 billion in interest, resulting in about $72 billion in lost federal tax revenue, the report says.

Fewer than half of all homeowners, and about a quarter of tax filers, claim the mortgage interest deduction, the report said. The benefit of the deduction increases with the size of the mortgage: the bigger the mortgage, the greater the tax benefit. (Currently, the amount of mortgage debt eligible for the interest rate deduction is capped at $1 million.)

The percentage of filers using the deduction varies widely by state. In Maryland, for instance, the percentage was about 37 percent, while in North Dakota and West Virginia, it’s about 15 percent.

The average deduction among all filers nationally (including those who don’t take the deduction) was $2,713 in 2010. But the average amounts ranged from a high of $4,580 in Maryland to a low of $1,192 in North Dakota. (The average is calculated over all tax filers, so the amounts can be compared geographically.)

Pew’s Web site features an interactive map that lets you see the average deduction in your state and ZIP code.

The report didn’t make any recommendations, but said the data shows that changes to federal tax policy could have varying results in the states.

Do you claim the home mortgage interest deduction? How important is it to you?


This post has been revised to reflect the following correction:

Correction: May 2, 2013

An earlier version of this post misstated the amount of federal tax revenue forgone in 2011 because of the mortgage interest deduction. It was $72 billion, not $72 million.

Article source: http://bucks.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/05/02/use-of-mortgage-interest-deduction-depends-on-where-you-live/?partner=rss&emc=rss

Economix: The Largest Tax Breaks for Individuals

The economist Eric Toder has pointed out that the largest corporate tax loopholes also happen to be among the most politically popular. They include the tax breaks for new machinery and for research and development. The policies don’t seem like corporate giveaways — though, to some extent, they are — as much as they seem like efforts to create jobs.

A version of this same problem exists within the tax code for individuals. Arguably, it’s worse. In Sunday’s Times Magazine, I have a column looking at the three largest tax breaks. All of them apply to individuals, not companies.

No. 1 is the tax exclusion for employer-provided health insurance. Last year’s health overhaul will start to shrink this loophole in coming years, but the pace will be slow. And the political fight was terribly bruising. Both labor unions and Republicans opposed the measure (which was often called the Cadillac tax).

Nos. 2 and 3 are the mortgage-interest deduction and the tax break for 401(k) contributions. None of these loopholes does a cost effective job of fostering the social goals they are meant to. And all benefit upper-income households — who have received the largest pretax raises in recent years — much more than lower-income households.

If Democrats and Republicans can come together to reduce these tax breaks, which will simplify the tax code and bring down the deficit, it will be very good news. It will also be surprising.

Article source: http://feeds.nytimes.com/click.phdo?i=bcb91cb7fc7fcf8989280711038d6425