November 5, 2024

To Sir, With Wrath: A Cautionary Tale From Middle England

Dick Fletcher of Hambledon, channeling Jane Austen, remarks that “It is a truth universally acknowledged that showing a little respect to one’s fellow human being (whether editor, animal, female, male or neither) never did anyone any harm.”

Allowing that the phrase may be old fashioned, he adds, “so is 1.5 oz of Bourbon or rye whiskey, two dashes of Angostura bitters, one sugar cube and a few dashes of plain water. How could one live without either.”

They go on like that. One correspondent says the decision “made me hold my head in despair,” while another is “saddened that I may no longer show my personal respect for you by addressing you as ‘Sir.’”

In the end, Mr. Bradshaw executes an about-face, writing that, “at the risk of reoffending Liz Hatch, I have not decided to heed the advice and leave it up to correspondents to decide whether to address me as ‘Sir’ or not and will publish their letters accordingly.”

Neither Mr. Bradshaw nor Ms. Hatch have commented further on the matter. But the dispute has sparked further analysis of “Sir,” as it is still used for letters to the editor in The Daily Telegraph, The Times, The Spectator and Private Eye, but has been dropped by The Guardian, The New Statesman, The Economist and The Financial Times.

Brooke Masters, the comment and analysis editor of The Financial Times, which phased out “Sir” in its letters section in April last year, said she had expected a much bigger backlash over the decision. “We got a couple of ‘What took you so longs,’ and a few ‘This is a depressing depersonalizations’ — there was some bemoaning in a nostalgic way,” she said. “I was really surprised. I thought we were going to get hundreds.”

The controversy has also, as a side note, drawn international attention to the literary skills of The Standard’s correspondents, in particular Simon Brickhill of Goring Heath, who wrote a letter that was headlined “Keeping to (short) point.” It read, in its entirety, as follows:

“Sir, — I’ll keep this brief. — Yours faithfully,”

Article source: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/01/world/europe/henley-standard-sir-england.html?partner=rss&emc=rss

Speak Your Mind